Skip to content

Clanzy vs VoiceMaster vs Carl-bot: Which Discord Bot Fits a Gaming Server?

An honest comparison for gaming servers: Carl-bot alternative for welcomes and roles, VoiceMaster alternative for temp voice, and when to keep each bot.

Author
The Clanzy team
Updated
Reading time
7 min read

Short answer

Carl-bot is a general-purpose bot with deep moderation, automod, logging and reaction roles, and no temp voice in its docs. VoiceMaster is a dedicated temp voice bot with more room options than anyone else here. Clanzy covers a gaming server's first three jobs (welcome, game roles, temp voice) with one /setup all, and since November 2026 also free moderation, anti-spam, logs, role panels and voice levels, so many servers can run it alone.

The Clanzy /setup all report listing the welcome channel, six game roles, a Member role, gender roles and the Create a room hub

If you run a gaming server, you have probably ended up with a small zoo of bots: Carl-bot for roles and moderation, VoiceMaster for voice rooms, maybe something else for welcomes. This page compares the three on the jobs gaming servers actually need, so you can decide what to keep, what to swap and what to run side by side.

Full disclosure: we make Clanzy. Everything we say about VoiceMaster and Carl-bot comes from their own public docs and websites (November 2026), and we say plainly where they are stronger.

The short version

  • Carl-bot is a general-purpose bot: reaction roles, autoroles, welcome and leave messages, automod, moderation, logging, tags (custom commands), levels, starboard, suggestions and feeds. Its docs list no temp voice feature.
  • VoiceMaster does one thing, join-to-create temp voice, and goes deep on it: permit and reject lists, bitrate, room text channels, channel status, several room-naming setups.
  • Clanzy handles the first three things a gaming server needs with one /setup all: a welcome card with a Get started button, intro questions that hand out game roles, and a ➕ Create a room hub. It defaults to Vietnamese with English available and never asks for Administrator. It also covers everyday moderation (warn, timeout, kick, ban, purge, case history, warn rules), anti-spam and anti-raid, server logs, button role panels and voice levels that count in temp rooms, all on the free plan.

Feature comparison

"Not in docs" means we did not find the feature in that bot's public docs or website (November 2026). It does not prove the bot can't do it.

FeatureClanzyVoiceMasterCarl-bot
Welcome message in a channelYesNot in docsYes
Welcome DMNoNot in docsYes
Role for everyone on join (autorole)PartlyNot in docsYes
Emoji reaction rolesNoNot in docsYes
Button or menu role panelsYesNot in docsYes
Intro questions that assign game rolesYesNot in docsNot in docs
Join-to-create temp voice roomsYesYesNot in docs
Owner lock, hide, rename, limit, claim, transferYesYesNot in docs
Bitrate, room text channel, channel statusNoYesNot in docs
Warn, timeout, kick, ban, case historyYesNot in docsYes
Anti-spam (invites, links, mentions, floods)YesNot in docsYes
Server logsYesNot in docsYes
Levels and XPYes, free, voice XP counts in temp roomsNot in docsYes (paid plan)
Custom commands, starboardNoNot in docsYes
One command sets up welcome, roles and voiceYesPartlyPartly
Web dashboardYesYesYes
Vietnamese by defaultYesNot in docsNot in docs
Paid planYesYesYes

The "Partly" cells: Clanzy gives its Member role when a newcomer finishes the intro questions, not the moment they join. VoiceMaster's /setup commands build the voice side only. Carl-bot has setup helpers per module (such as /reactionrole setup and /modlog create) rather than one command for everything.

Welcome messages

Carl-bot's greetings are flexible. You set a welcome channel, optionally DM the member, and use variables like {mention}, {server} and {server(members)}, plus Tagscript for more logic. It also does leave and ban messages; per its docs, a dedicated farewell channel is a Premium command. If you want a highly scripted welcome, Carl-bot does more than Clanzy.

Clanzy posts a welcome card with a Get started button. You write the text on the dashboard with {user}, {username}, {server} and {memberCount}. The difference is what happens next: the button opens the intro questions, so the greeting leads straight to roles. With membership screening on, Clanzy waits until the newcomer accepts the rules and welcomes them once. More in our Discord welcome bot guide.

VoiceMaster's site does not cover welcomes.

Roles

Carl-bot's reaction roles are the most complete of the three. Each message can be unique (one role at a time), verify (add only), binding, or drop, with limits on how many roles a member takes and how many people can hold a role. Add autoroles, delayed roles, and sticky roles for members who rejoin within 30 days. If you need those rules, Carl-bot is the stronger choice.

Clanzy takes a different route: newcomers press Get started, choose a gender (optional) and the games they play from a menu, up to 25 games. Picked games add roles, unpicked games remove them, and /roles lets anyone change their answers. Every newcomer sees the question in the welcome card. The auto role guide walks through the setup. For rank, region or ping roles, Clanzy also posts self-role panels with buttons or a select menu, one choice or several, with an optional maximum.

Temp voice

This is VoiceMaster's home turf. Per its site, room owners can lock, ghost (hide), rename, limit, claim and transfer, and also permit or reject specific users or roles, change bitrate and region, set a channel status, send invites, and open a text channel private to the room. Admins choose between a free default setup, paid Sequential, Predefined and Clone setups, and a newer Dynamic setup. If your server lives in voice and wants that control, VoiceMaster offers more than Clanzy.

Clanzy covers the core flow. Join ➕ Create a room and you get a room named after you (template 🎮 {displayName}, editable on the dashboard), with a button panel to lock, hide, rename, set a limit, claim, transfer ownership or kick. Kicked members are blocked from rejoining. Everything also works as /voice ... commands, and rooms delete themselves once they have been empty for 2 minutes, so a member whose console or phone drops can rejoin. Time in temp rooms counts toward Clanzy's free voice levels. The free plan includes one hub.

Carl-bot's docs show voice logging (joins, moves, leaves) but no temp voice rooms.

A Clanzy temp room named after its owner under the Temp rooms category, with two members inside

Permissions and privacy

Clanzy asks for manage channels, manage roles, view channels, send messages, embed links, read message history, connect and move members, plus the moderation permissions (timeout, kick and ban members, manage messages, view audit log). It never asks for Administrator, never acts on admins, and never stores message content. VoiceMaster's official invite link does not request Administrator either. For Carl-bot, check the permission list on the invite screen; a moderation bot needs permissions like kick and ban to do its job.

When to pick which

Pick Carl-bot if you need custom commands (tags), starboard, emoji reaction roles with many rules or its deeper automod. Clanzy now covers everyday moderation, anti-spam, logs and role panels, but not those.

Pick VoiceMaster if voice is the center of your server and members want fine control: permit lists, bitrate, room text channels, numbered rooms.

Pick Clanzy if you are building a gaming server, or cleaning one up, and want welcome, game roles, temp voice, moderation, logs and voice levels from one bot set up in minutes, with copy that reads naturally in Vietnamese or English.

Run two together only if you need something Clanzy lacks, like Carl-bot's tags. Turn off the duplicate modules (welcome, logs) in one of them so newcomers are not greeted twice.

How to switch

From VoiceMaster or another temp voice bot

  1. Add Clanzy with the Add to Discord button at the top of this page.
  2. Type /setup voice to create a 🔊 Temp rooms category and a ➕ Create a room hub.
  3. Try it for a few minutes: join the hub, check the room and its control panel.
  4. Delete the old bot's hub. Rooms with people in them stay until everyone leaves.
  5. Remove the old bot if you don't use it for anything else.

If you run several hubs today, note that Clanzy's free plan has one.

From Carl-bot welcomes and game reaction roles

  1. Type /setup all (or /setup onboarding). Existing roles with the same name are reused when Clanzy can assign them.
  2. On the dashboard, map each game to your existing game role.
  3. In Server Settings → Roles, drag the Clanzy role above those game roles.
  4. Turn off Carl-bot's welcome message in its dashboard.
  5. Run /setup welcome-test and press Get started to try it as a newcomer.
  6. Run /setup logs for a mod log channel and set your warn rules in the dashboard. Keep Carl-bot only for features Clanzy lacks.

Every slash command is on the Clanzy commands page, and the Pro and Own bot plans are on pricing.

Sources (checked November 2026): Carl-bot docs at docs.carl.gg (Greetings, Roles, Logging, Premium); VoiceMaster's homepage and setup guide at voicemaster.xyz.

Questions people ask

Is Clanzy a full Carl-bot alternative?

For most gaming servers, yes. Clanzy covers welcomes, game roles, button role panels, warn/timeout/kick/ban with case history and warn rules, anti-spam, logs and voice levels, all free. It has no tags (custom commands), starboard or social feeds, and Carl-bot's reaction-role rules and automod go deeper. If you rely on those, keep Carl-bot for them.

Does Carl-bot have temp voice channels?

Not according to its public docs (November 2026). It logs members joining, moving between and leaving voice channels, but has no join-to-create rooms.

Is Clanzy a good VoiceMaster alternative?

For the core flow, yes: join a hub, get your own room, lock, hide, rename, limit, claim, transfer or kick with buttons. VoiceMaster offers more room options, such as bitrate, permit lists, room text channels and numbered rooms.

Can I run Clanzy alongside Carl-bot or VoiceMaster?

Yes. Turn off the welcome message in one bot so newcomers are not greeted twice, and use only one join-to-create hub per room setup.

How much does Clanzy cost?

Welcome messages, intro questions, game roles, temp voice, moderation, anti-spam, logs, role panels and voice levels are free. The free plan includes one create-a-room hub and up to 25 onboarding games.